Engineering Change Request (ECR):Process, Form & Example
An Engineering Change Request (ECR) is a formal proposal to evaluate a product or process change before implementation is approved. Explore the ECR form, seven-stage review process, practical example, and transition to an Engineering Change Order (ECO).

Evaluate change before implementation.
Capture, assess, and decide.
The Engineering Change Request gives teams a controlled decision path before revisions or execution begin.
Document what needs to change
Identify the problem, business justification, and affected items before any implementation begins.
Explore the ECR process
Gather cross-functional evidence
Review technical feasibility, supplier risk, cost, quality, manufacturing, and schedule effects.
Explore the ECR processRecord the decision and next action
Approve, reject, defer or request more details. Only approved changes proceed to a controlled ECO.
Explore the ECR processWhat Is an Engineering Change Request?
An Engineering Change Request is a formal proposal used to identify, document, and evaluate a potential change to a product, component, document, manufacturing process, software application, or related engineering data.
The purpose of an ECR is to decide whether a proposed change is justified, feasible, and sufficiently understood to proceed. Reviewers examine the reason for change, affected parts or assemblies, design documentation, product configurations, risks, cost, and schedule. An ECR does not itself authorize implementation; an approved request normally moves to a controlled Engineering Change Order (ECO).
Formal Proposal
Captures why a change is being considered.
Evaluation Gate
Ensures analysis happens before execution.
ECO Precursor
Feeds approved changes into the implementation stage.
An ECR evaluates whether a proposed change should proceed. It does not authorize teams to implement a change before approval.
Common Reasons Teams Create an ECR
Engineering Change Requests can originate from many different sources across the product lifecycle, but most requests cluster around a small set of recurring triggers.
Product Quality Issues
Defects discovered during testing, production, or customer use often require formal evaluation before corrective action is approved.
Design Improvements
Teams may propose changes to improve performance, reliability, safety, manufacturability, or usability.
Cost Reduction
Alternative materials, components, suppliers, or production methods can lower cost but may introduce other tradeoffs.
Supplier Changes
Discontinuations, sourcing risks, approved vendor updates, or supply instability often trigger an ECR.
Regulatory Requirements
Compliance changes may require controlled revisions to products, documentation, or production methods.
Manufacturing Challenges
Production inefficiencies, tooling constraints, or assembly difficulties can justify a formal request for change.
Additional triggers include customer feedback, component obsolescence, and process improvements. When a proposed change affects specifications, drawings, or released instructions, connect the request to the relevant controlled product documents rather than evaluating it in isolation.
Engineering Change Request Form: Required Fields
A useful ECR form identifies the requested change, establishes the current product baseline, and provides the evidence reviewers need for a documented decision. The exact fields vary by company and change classification.
Change Definition
Start with the essentials so reviewers immediately understand what is being proposed and why it entered the workflow.
- Change description
- Business justification
- Problem statement
Scope and Impacted Objects
The request should make the scope explicit so teams can understand exactly what may need to be touched downstream.
- Affected items
- Affected end items
- Affected documents
Evaluation Context
Decision-makers need enough information to judge whether the change is worth pursuing before implementation work begins.
- Initial risk assessment
- Expected benefits
- Supporting business impact
Completed ECR Form Example
This illustrative record shows how a supplier discontinuation can be documented before a replacement is approved. Product names and request identifiers below are fictional examples, not actual Nora IPLM customer data.
| ECR information | Example |
|---|---|
| Request ID | ECR-0147 (illustrative) |
| Request title | Evaluate replacement battery mounting bracket |
| Priority and current status | High priority · Under cross-functional review |
| Submission and review target | Record the date submitted and the proposed review deadline |
| Change reason | Supplier component discontinuation |
| Requested by | Manufacturing Engineer |
| Current part revision | BRK-1001, current approved revision to be confirmed |
| Affected item | Battery Mounting Bracket BRK-1001 |
| Affected end items | Forklift EF-2000 and EF-2500 |
| Related BOMs | Forklift drive and battery assemblies |
| Related documents | Drawing, specification, supplier documentation |
| Proposed solution | Qualify and introduce replacement bracket |
| Engineering impact | Interface and mounting verification |
| Manufacturing impact | Assembly and tooling review |
| Procurement impact | New supplier and lead-time evaluation |
| Cost impact | Replacement component and qualification cost |
| Risk | Supply interruption if replacement is delayed |
| Decision | Pending: approve, reject, defer, or request additional information |
| Supporting evidence | Supplier notice, drawings, proposed replacement specification, feasibility review |
| Review ownership | Engineering, Manufacturing, Procurement, Quality and change approver |
| Next change object | ECO if approved |
How to Write an Engineering Change Request
A strong request allows engineering, manufacturing, procurement, and quality reviewers to evaluate the same proposal without chasing missing information. Use this practical sequence when preparing an ECR.
State the problem and desired outcome
Describe what is happening today, why it matters, and what the proposed change is intended to accomplish. Identify whether the trigger is a defect, supplier issue, cost objective, compliance need, or design improvement.
Identify affected product data
Record the relevant part numbers, current revisions, drawings, assemblies, affected end items, and BOMs. Use the current released baseline so reviewers can distinguish the proposed future state from the product that exists today.
Record impacts, risks, and evidence
Summarize technical feasibility, validation needs, supplier availability, production or tooling effects, likely costs, and schedule implications. Attach supplier notices, test results, specifications, or other evidence where available.
Request a review, not an implementation
Assign an owner and review target, identify the stakeholders who need to assess the change, and document the decision criteria. Keep implementation tasks and new released revisions under the subsequent ECO when approval is granted.
Example: Make the change request specific
“Replace the forklift bracket because the supplier changed.”
“Supplier discontinuation affects bracket BRK-1001 used in forklift models EF-2000 and EF-2500. Evaluate replacement options for mechanical fit, tooling, quality verification, cost, and supply continuity before approving the change.”
Once the proposal is complete, route the record through the appropriate PLM review and approval workflow and preserve the reasons for the final decision.
Engineering Change Request Process
Seven stages from proposal to approval.
An ECR approval workflow typically starts with a documented problem, moves through cross-functional impact analysis, and ends with a recorded decision. An approved ECR can then initiate an ECO for implementation.
Identify the Need
A product defect, supplier discontinuation, design improvement, regulatory need, or manufacturing issue creates the need to evaluate a change.
- Identify the issue or product improvement.
- Capture the operational or business need.
Create the ECR
The requester records the proposed outcome, reason for change, affected item numbers and revisions, supporting evidence, and an accountable request owner.
- Record the proposal and justification.
- Link affected items, end items and supporting documents.
Initial Review
A coordinator or designated reviewer checks completeness, change classification, priority, and affected product data before starting a broader impact assessment.
- Check that the request has enough information for evaluation.
- Return incomplete records for clarification.
Impact Analysis
Engineering, manufacturing, quality, procurement, and other relevant functions assess feasibility, BOM and document impact, inventory exposure, validation needs, cost, and schedule.
- Assess technical, manufacturing, supplier, cost and compliance impacts.
- Identify feasibility, risk and likely scheduling effects.
Board Evaluation
The appropriate reviewers evaluate the documented proposal, evidence, risks, and alternatives against the organization’s approval rules.
- Route the request to the relevant review board.
- Gather accountable cross-functional decisions.
Decision
The approver records whether the request is approved, rejected, deferred, or needs more information, along with the reasons, conditions, and responsible next owner.
- Approve, reject, defer or return for more information.
- Preserve the decision and its rationale.
Create the ECO
When implementation is authorized, a linked Engineering Change Order defines the approved scope, downstream revisions, tasks, verification, and release controls.
- Create a connected ECO only after approval.
- Carry approved scope and context into controlled implementation.
Engineering Change Request Example: Supplier Discontinuation
In this illustrative forklift scenario, a supplier announces plans to discontinue a battery mounting bracket. The ECR is used to identify which products depend on the part, assess replacement options, and document an approval decision before any controlled revision begins.
Affected Item
Battery Mounting Bracket (BRK-1001) is identified as the component directly impacted by the proposed change.
Affected End Items
Electric Forklift Model EF-2000 and Electric Forklift Model EF-2500 may both be impacted by the bracket change.
Analysis Inputs
The request captures supplier discontinuation risk, potential replacement components, manufacturing impact, procurement impact, and cost considerations.
Outcome
After the required stakeholders complete impact analysis, the Change Review Board approves the ECR. The approved request is then connected to an ECO that controls the actual replacement activity, resulting revisions, BOM updates, implementation tasks, verification, and release.
Cross-functional review checklist
- Engineering: Can the proposed replacement meet the same functional and interface requirements?
- Manufacturing: Will the new bracket affect assembly, tooling, work instructions, or production processes?
- Procurement: Is the replacement component available from an approved supplier at the required cost and lead time?
- Quality: Does the new component require additional inspection, validation, or qualification?
- Product Management: Which forklift configurations and customer-deliverable products are affected?
ECR vs ECO: Evaluation and Execution
One of the most common points of confusion is the difference between an Engineering Change Request and an Engineering Change Order. The distinction is simple once the intent of each object is clear.
| Engineering Change Request (ECR) | Engineering Change Order (ECO) |
|---|---|
| Identifies a problem or opportunity | Authorizes implementation |
| Evaluates feasibility | Governs execution |
| Focuses on analysis | Focuses on implementation |
| Determines whether a change should occur | Defines how the change will occur |
| Early-stage activity | Post-approval activity |
Think of the ECR as the evaluation record and the ECO as the implementation control. Both should remain linked so the reason for change, approval, assignments, revisions, and verification can be traced. For a deeper side-by-side explanation, read ECR vs ECO, then explore the Engineering Change Order guide.
Engineering Change Request Best Practices
Incomplete forms, email-only reviews, unclear owners, and missing product links can slow decisions. Standardized request information and defined approval criteria make the process easier to review and audit. For broader improvements, see these engineering change process best practices.
Incomplete Requests
Missing information delays evaluation and decision-making.
Improve it: Standardize Templates. Use consistent forms, fields, and required information so every request starts with the same baseline quality.
Email-Based Reviews
Approvals become difficult to track, audit, and manage.
Improve it: Automate Workflows. Reduce delays through workflow automation, routing, and notifications.
Limited Visibility
Teams cannot easily determine request status, ownership, or bottlenecks.
Improve it: Define Review Ownership. Make participation and approval responsibilities explicit across departments.
Slow Decision Cycles
Requests remain pending while stakeholders wait on fragmented feedback loops.
Improve it: Require Impact Analysis. Evaluate technical, operational, financial, and compliance implications before approval.
Weak Traceability
Organizations struggle to connect approved requests to downstream implementation activities.
Improve it: Maintain Full Traceability. Track every decision, approval, comment, and status change throughout the request lifecycle.
Keep Requests Connected
Link requests directly to affected items, affected end items, BOMs, documents, requirements, projects, and related data.
Improve it: Connect product data, preserve approval history and monitor review performance.
How PLM Improves ECR Management
Managing ECRs through spreadsheets, email threads, and shared folders often creates confusion and delay. PLM systems provide a centralized environment where teams can evaluate requests in context and maintain a complete history of decisions.
What PLM Centralizes
- Create and manage ECRs
- Route reviews automatically
- Track approval status
- Maintain revision history
- Monitor change metrics
What Better Context Looks Like
- Connect requests to affected items and affected end items
- Link directly to BOM structures and controlled documents
- Preserve comments, approvals, and traceability in one workflow
- Reduce operational risk through better visibility
How Nora IPLM Helps
- Create and manage ECRs in the same system as products and documents
- Configure approval workflows
- Route requests to cross-functional reviewers
- Convert approved requests into Engineering Change Orders
- Maintain complete traceability across the request lifecycle
A request can stay connected to affected items, product configurations, BOMs and documents. Nora IPLM Change Management maintains the evaluation context as an approved request advances into controlled ECO work.
Engineering Change Resource Library
Explore the Change Management module and related guides on engineering change evaluation, implementation and process improvement.
Nora IPLM Change Management Module
Connect change requests, orders, approval workflows and product data in one controlled platform.
Explore ModuleEngineering Change Order (ECO) Guide
Understand what happens after approval, including implementation, revisions, tasks and verification.
Read GuideEngineering Change Management Guide
Explore how ECRs, ECOs, approvals and traceability work together throughout the change lifecycle.
Read GuideECR vs ECO: What’s the Difference?
Compare the review and execution stages to clarify when each controlled record is required.
Read GuideEngineering Change Process Best Practices
Learn approaches for faster approvals, clearer ownership and fewer implementation bottlenecks.
Read GuideFrequently
Asked
Questions
Common questions about Engineering Change Requests
What is an Engineering Change Request?
An Engineering Change Request is a formal proposal used to evaluate a potential product or process change before implementation is authorized.
What is the purpose of an ECR?
The purpose of an ECR is to assess the feasibility, impact, risks, and benefits of a proposed change before implementation begins.
Who creates an Engineering Change Request?
ECRs can be created by engineers, manufacturing teams, quality personnel, procurement teams, product managers, suppliers, or other stakeholders who identify a need for change.
What happens after an ECR is approved?
The approved proposal can be connected to an Engineering Change Order (ECO). The ECO manages implementation scope, ownership, required revisions, tasks, verification, and release. Approval of the ECR should not be confused with completion of the change.
What are affected items in an ECR?
Affected items are the specific parts, assemblies, documents, software components, or managed objects that are directly impacted by the proposed change.
What are affected end items in an ECR?
Affected end items are the finished products, configurations, or customer-deliverable products that may be impacted by changes made to the affected items.
What is the difference between an ECR and an ECO?
An ECR evaluates whether a change should occur. An ECO authorizes and manages the implementation of an approved change.
How does PLM support ECR management?
PLM software keeps the proposal, affected parts and BOMs, review participants, evidence, and decision history connected. Configurable workflows help route reviews and link an approved ECR to the ECO that controls implementation.
What should an engineering change request form include?
An ECR form normally includes a request ID, title, requester, reason for change, problem statement, proposed solution, affected parts and revisions, impacted end items, supporting documents, risk and impact assessment, priority, owner, and approval decision. Fields should match the organization’s workflow and level of risk.
How do you write a clear Engineering Change Request?
Explain the current issue, describe the desired outcome, identify the affected product records and their revisions, attach supporting evidence, and summarize the likely technical, manufacturing, cost, supplier, and schedule effects. Keep the request focused on evaluation rather than prematurely authorizing implementation.
Can an ECR be rejected or deferred?
Yes. Reviewers may reject a request when the proposed change is not justified or suitable, defer it until a later date, or return it for more evidence. Capture the reason, responsible owner, and next action so the evaluation record remains traceable.
Review Changes with the Full Product Context.
Nora IPLM Change Management
Connect Engineering Change Requests to affected items, BOMs, drawings, approval workflows, and the ECOs that implement approved decisions. Keep the reason for change and the evidence behind each decision accessible in one place.